top of page

STAY IN THE KNOW-Be the first to read our blogs when they come out!

Thanks for submitting!

Writer's pictureSusan Ardila

Why Most Math Homework is Useless: An Educator’s Bold Claim for More Effective Learning

Updated: May 22


Ah, math homework. The bane of many a student's existence and the source of countless parent-teacher conference debates. Now, before you clutch your pearls or start drafting an angry comment, let me explain my seemingly blasphemous assertion. As someone who has navigated the choppy waters of education with the compass of ADHD, I've seen firsthand the pitfalls of traditional math homework. And folks, it's time for a revolution.


As we delve deeper into the discussion of reshaping our approach to math education, keep in mind that the revolution starts with informed choices. Choosing Susan Ardila's Math Wizdom is the first step towards changing the narrative around math homework from one of dread to one of discovery and success. Take that first step now and go online to Book Your Personalized Tutoring Sessions today!


Ok, let's get to it!


The Homework Conundrum:

First off, let's address the elephant in the room. A substantial portion of students either don't do their homework, borrow it (let's be honest, copy it) from a friend, or worse, diligently complete it while engraving all the wrong answers into their brains. It's like practicing the violin with the strings tuned wrong; no matter how much you practice; you're not going to make beautiful music.


The Domino Effect of Misguided Learning


Upset student completing homework
When students complete homework incorrectly and have no one to immediately correct them, all those inaccuracies are getting embedded in their brains. It's a no-win situation.

Consider this: a student diligently completes an entire math assignment incorrectly, unknowingly ingraining the wrong methodologies into their thought processes. Breaking such misconceptions can be a Herculean task, taking precious time away from moving forward in the curriculum. The real question becomes, why put our children through this cycle of error when there might be a more effective alternative?


Let's take a peek at what research says. A systematic review comparing online versus traditional homework found that the latter often fails to excite students, making them less likely to engage meaningfully with the material (ScienceDirect, 2020). Furthermore, studies exploring the effectiveness of web-based homework in subjects like calculus and statistics suggest that these innovative approaches can be just as effective, if not more so, than traditional pencil-and-paper torture—I mean, assignments (LearnTechLib, 2009; Wiley Online Library, 2008).


Counterargument Alert: Practice Makes Perfect?

"But wait!" I hear you protest, "Isn't homework necessary for practice and reinforcement!" I can almost hear the collective sighs of agreement. Sure, in theory. However, when traditional methods leave a significant portion of our young learners disengaged, confused, or suffering from undue stress, it's clear we need a new game plan. You wouldn't practice swimming in a puddle when you have an ocean of opportunities, right? In my scatter-brained wisdom, let's dive into the alternatives.


Flipping the Script: The Case for Flipped Classrooms:


Flipped classroom icon
Flipped Classroom: Students interact with new material at home first, then work on their new knowledge in class where their teacher can correct any inaccuracies.

Enter the concept of the flipped classroom, a beacon of hope in the murky waters of educational reform. The idea is simple yet revolutionary: students engage with new material at home, through reading or video lessons, and then apply what they've learned in class, with a teacher on hand to guide them through the murky depths. Sounds great, right? Except, there's a catch. Those same students who were allergic to traditional homework? They're not suddenly going to develop an insatiable thirst for knowledge just because we flipped the script.


So, where does that leave us? Stuck between a rock and a hard place, with half the class ready to move forward and the other half still trying to figure out where the play button is on their video lesson. Not exactly the educational utopia we were hoping for.


Embracing Innovation: A New Dawn for Math Education

But fear not, dear readers, for all is not lost. After diving headfirst into the sea of educational research (and getting a little distracted by videos of cats playing piano), I've surfaced with a treasure trove of innovative methods for teaching math at home that don't rely on traditional homework. These strategies are designed to engage students across all age groups and learning styles, ensuring that learning math feels more like discovering a hidden cove of pirate treasure and less like walking the plank.


  1. Interactive Online Platforms: -How it works: Platforms like Khan Academy, Prodigy, and Desmos offer interactive lessons, games, and challenges. -Why it's effective: These platforms provide instant feedback, adapt to individual learning styles, and make math enjoyable through gamification. -Benefits: Engages students, promotes independent learning, and allows for personalized progression. -Actionable steps: Encourage regular use, monitor progress, and set goals within the platform.

  2. Educational Apps: -How it works: Apps such as DragonBox Numbers or Photomath turn math learning into interactive games or provide step-by-step solutions through the camera. -Why it's effective: Makes learning fun, visual, and allows for immediate problem-solving feedback. -Benefits: Enhances visual understanding, reinforces concepts through repetition, and provides a different perspective. -Actionable steps: Integrate app usage into daily routines, discuss challenges, and celebrate achievements.

  3. Real-World Applications: -How it works: Integrate math into daily life activities like budgeting, cooking, or planning trips. -Why it's effective: Makes math relevant and practical, reinforcing its importance in real-world scenarios. -Benefits: Develops critical thinking, problem-solving skills, and enhances applicability. -Actionable steps: Involve children in everyday tasks, discuss math applications, and explore real-world math problems together.

  4. Virtual Math Challenges: -How it works: Organize virtual math challenges or competitions using platforms like Zoom or Google Meet. -Why it's effective: Fosters friendly competition, collaboration, and engagement. -Benefits: Builds a sense of achievement, encourages teamwork, and makes math a social activity. -Actionable steps: Arrange regular challenges, create a leaderboard, and provide small incentives for participation.

  5. Math Storytelling: -How it works: Create narratives or scenarios where math concepts are essential to solving problems. -Why it's effective: Enhances understanding by placing math in a context that is relatable and interesting. -Benefits: Develops critical thinking, promotes creativity, and improves retention. -Actionable steps: Share math-related stories, encourage children to create their own math narratives, and discuss the connections between stories and concepts.

  6. Peer-to-Peer Learning: -How it works: Facilitate virtual study groups or partnerships where students can collaborate on math problems. -Why it's effective: Promotes peer learning, diverse perspectives, and social interaction. -Benefits: Encourages communication skills, builds confidence, and provides different problem-solving approaches. -Actionable steps: Connect students with similar learning levels, schedule regular virtual study sessions, and encourage open discussions.

  7. Virtual Field Trips: -How it works: Explore mathematical concepts in art museums, architecture, or nature through virtual field trips. -Why it's effective: Provides a visual and practical understanding of math in various contexts. -Benefits: Enhances visual learning, makes math more tangible, and broadens the understanding of its applications. -Actionable steps: Research virtual field trip opportunities, plan interactive discussions afterward, and encourage reflection on the mathematical aspects observed.

  8. Math Puzzles and Riddles: -How it works: Introduce challenging puzzles and riddles that require problem-solving skills. -Why it's effective: Develops critical thinking, logic, and persistence in solving mathematical problems. -Benefits: Makes learning enjoyable, fosters a positive attitude toward challenges, and enhances problem-solving abilities. -Actionable steps: Provide a variety of puzzles, gradually increase difficulty, and celebrate successful solutions.

  9. Personalized Learning Plans: -How it works: Tailor learning plans to individual students' needs using diagnostic tools. -Why it's effective: Addresses specific strengths and weaknesses, allowing for a customized learning experience. -Benefits: Maximizes efficiency, adapts to different learning styles, and focuses on areas that need improvement. -Actionable steps: Assess students' current proficiency, set achievable goals, and regularly reassess to adjust the learning plan.

  10. Parent Involvement: -How it works: Encourage parents to actively support their child's learning at home through workshops or webinars. -Why it's effective: Provides parents with tools to understand the current math curriculum and support their child's learning journey. -Benefits: Strengthens the home-school connection, ensures consistency in learning approaches, and fosters a supportive learning environment. -Actionable steps: Offer informative workshops, share online resources, and facilitate open communication channels between parents and educators.


A Balancing Act: Homework and Well-being


Stressed out student
Excessive homework can lead to unhealthy levels of stress.

As we unravel the mysteries of effective learning, it's vital to consider the well-being of our young learners. Excessive homework can cast a shadow on students' mental health and overall well-being, leading to stress, sleep deprivation, and diminished personal development. But fear not! We hold the key to a brighter future. By embracing shorter, focused assignments and incorporating self-reflection and mindfulness practices, we can create a harmonious blend of learning and well-being.


Studies have shown a connection between excessive homework and increased stress levels in students. The American Psychological Association has cited research indicating that excessive homework can lead to sleep deprivation, unhealthy levels of stress, and other health problems in students. This suggests that excessive homework can have a detrimental effect on students' mental and physical health.


Furthermore, a study conducted by Stanford Graduate School of Education found that excessive homework can have harmful effects on students' well-being, leading to increased stress and reduced engagement with learning. This highlights the potential negative impact of excessive homework on students' overall mental health and well-being.


A Kinder Approach to Learning:

Implementing shorter, focused assignments and incorporating self-reflection and mindfulness practices can foster a harmonious blend of learning and well-being for students, paving the way for a more holistic and positive learning experience.


Your Journey to Math Mastery Begins Here


A group of elementary school children
Say good-bye to traditional homework and embrace inclusive learning adventures!

Let's close the curtains on this captivating tale and invite you to reimagine math education at home. Say goodbye to traditional math homework constraints and embrace inclusive learning adventures! Whether your child loves educational apps or hands-on activities, innovative learning methods bring joy, understanding, and inspiration to math. 🌟


Join us! Go online to Book Your Personalized Tutoring Sessions with Math Wisdom and ignite the magic of math in your child's learning journey! ✨ Let's not just believe in magic - let's create it together!


It's time to bid adieu to old-school math homework and usher in a new era of engaging, effective, and fun learning. Come on, fellow adventurers, let's navigate towards this exciting new world. Who knows? We might find that math isn't so daunting after all. 🚀


283 views0 comments

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Join the Club

Join our email list and get access to our blogs first! You'll also be the first to know about any deals we may offer or announcements we make.

Thanks for subscribing!

bottom of page